Philippine Taekwondo Kid Seen as Bully Rather then Hero
"The reason the anti-bully movement is so popular is the same reason it is failing so dismally: everyone thinks the bully is someone else." —Izzy Kalman
Martial arts are often recommended as a solution for victims of bullying. It's generally good advice. However, martial arts are far from a panacea for bullying. I have had clients that were victims of bullying despite having black belts. And there is a good reason the martial arts training didn't stop them from being bullied. Most bullying is verbal. What are you supposed to do when someone insults you — smash their teeth out? Social exclusion is also a common form of bullying. Will beating up those who don’t want to talk to you make you more popular? Unless the instructor teaches kids how to handle non-physical confrontations, the bullying is likely to continue.
In fact, kids can use the others' martial arts training to frustrate them, as in the accompanying illustration drawn by my daughter, Lola. In nature, where might mades right, you have to be insane to attack more dangerous individuals. They will tear you to pieces. In civilization, there is the rule of law. You can pick on stronger people, and if they dare to hit you, you inform the authorities and now they're in really big trouble. You thus use their own power against them to defeat them.
Today, victims can be charged as bullies when they use their martial arts skills to get even with their tormentors. This is apparently what happened to a "bully" at Ateneo Junior High School in Manilla, in a story that has caused an uproar in the Philippines and been a major concern of the news media. (Do a search for "Ataneo bully," and you will get a barrage of links to news stories.) A video was disseminated of a diminutive boy using Taekwondo to intimidate and beat up kids twice his size. In fact, one of them was sent to the hospital with fractured bones. The video has apparently become recently banned from the Internet, so it is difficult to find, but you can get a good sense of its content here. The boy was immediately deemed a bully by the news media, and the Department of Education kicked him out of school. The Philippine Taekwondo Association also condemned the boy’s actions and has banned him from competing.
But there's something very wrong with this story that no one is addressing. Isn’t a bully supposedly a cowardly brute picking on kids smaller and weaker than themselves? This boy is obviously not a coward. He is taking on kids much bigger than himself. And he is obviously an accomplished taekwando student. He was certainly taught to use his skills only for self-defense, and even then, only to use minimum force. Also, the video was probably filmed at his request, to document his conquests. Why would he want to create evidence of criminal attacks that can be used against him?
It's because something else was probably going on...
There are countless stories of successful martial artists whose attribute their careers to being bullied as kids. We unfailingly see these characters as heroes. Coincidentally, only a week ago my son, who is a martial arts aficionado, showed me a powerful short documentary of this nature called BULLY PROOF: The Story of GSP’s Evolution from Bully Victim to UFC Badass. (Unfortunately, you need a paid subscription to watch it, but Youtube has a shorter film about his experience.)
GPS is George St. Pierre (GSP), one of the greatest mixed martial artists in history. The film is a dramatization of his experience as a boy. He was small for his age and bullied terribly. His father sent him to study martial arts. When George was ready, he clobbered his main bully, and his days as a victim were history. This film has certainly been an inspiration to many young victims of bullying, and I would not be at all surprised if the Ateneo "bully" was one of them.
Thus, the most plausible explanation of the Ateneo story was that the boy had been bullied for years, perhaps his entire school career. His parents sent him to study taekwondo, and finally he felt ready to take on his bullies, perhaps even with his parents' blessing. He instructed a friend to film his revenge, expecting to be seen as a hero, just like GPS and countless others.
But there was something the boy didn't take into account, leading to his undoing. The video didn't show his previous history, only his apparently unprovoked, horrific attacks against innocent bystanders. So rather than earning the public's admiration as a victim overcoming his bullies, he earned notoriety as a cruel bully.
This story should also throw light on a problem with the academic definition of bullying, formulated by the creator of the field of bullying psychology, Prof. Dan Olweus, and universally accepted in all official domains. This definition is supposed to clarify what bullying is. However, as discovered by every school that tries to use this definition, it is not at all easy to determine when an act constitutes bullying.















